A clearer starting point
Understanding a buyer's bid
A bid is the price a buyer offers for specified gold or silver. Whether that price is an estimate or a firm offer depends on its terms. It is different from a market reference price and from the price a dealer asks when selling a coin. To compare offers, look at the amount you would receive and the conditions attached to it.
The short answer
Buyers commonly use a metal reference price when pricing bullion, then account for the product, quantity, condition and current demand, as well as their costs and margin. Some offers include all charges; others have separate deductions. Compare the same items at the same time, using the net proceeds and the written terms.
The reference: spot
Spot refers to the current cash-market price for metal for prompt settlement. U.S. gold and silver quotes are commonly shown in dollars per troy ounce. A troy ounce is approximately 31.1035 grams; an ordinary ounce is approximately 28.3495 grams. A market reference is not a purchase offer for your particular coins or bars. Check whether a displayed price is a spot quote, an auction benchmark or a futures price, and whether it is current or delayed. LBMA gold and silver benchmarks are established at scheduled auctions; they are distinct from continuously changing dealer quotes. When an offer is expressed as a percentage of spot, ask which reference, quote side and timestamp apply.
Your product, not just your metal
- Fine content, not gross weight. The one-ounce American Gold Eagle contains one full troy ounce of pure gold. It is a 22-karat alloy: the added silver and copper bring the coin’s total weight to approximately 1.0909 troy ounces (33.931 grams). That is its gross weight, not its gold content. The U.S. Mint lists the American Buffalo gold bullion coin as .9999 fine, with a nominal weight of one troy ounce. Fine gold or silver content multiplied by the corresponding reference price gives an indicative value for that metal, before product premiums, discounts or costs. It does not establish the amount a buyer must pay.
- Product. Recognition and current demand can affect resale opportunities and the price a buyer offers. A familiar product name alone does not guarantee a particular premium or bid.
- Quantity. If a charge applies once per shipment, it has a larger effect per coin in a smaller sale. Ask whether the price or any fee changes with quantity.
- Condition and packaging. Ordinary bullion is valued primarily for its metal content, but damage or missing product-specific packaging can affect an offer. Proof finish, a grading label or a “limited” description does not by itself establish a resale premium. Collector value depends on the particular coin and its market. The CFTC has warned about high-markup collectible-coin sales and the difficulty of recovering those markups. A premium paid when buying is not guaranteed when selling.
Bid, ask and the space between
A dealer’s bid is its offered buying price; its ask is its offered selling price. The bid–ask spread is the difference between those prices for the same product at the same time on comparable terms. This differs from a product’s premium or discount relative to a metal reference price. The spread alone does not tell you the dealer’s net profit or your total transaction costs.
A physical coin’s bid can be below, at or above the value of its precious-metal content calculated using a spot reference. Product demand and the terms of the offer matter; spot is not a guaranteed minimum or maximum. The U.S. Mint charges authorized purchasers a metal-based price plus a premium for its bullion coins. Retail pricing may include further costs and margins, and a resale bid may recover some, all or none of a previously paid premium. Compare current offers for your particular items instead of assuming that a past purchase price or a spot quote determines their resale price.
What comes off the bid
Ask which charges are already included and which, if any, will be deducted separately: shipping, insurance, testing or assay, and payment fees. Get the terms in writing so that costs are neither overlooked nor counted twice. For IRA-held metals, also check your custodian’s and depository’s applicable charges. Compare both the payment from the buyer and any separate costs charged to you or the IRA account.
When the price is fixed
Two bids with the same figure can be very different promises. Ask each buyer:
- At what moment is the price fixed: when you agree, when the metal arrives, or after it has been inspected?
- How long is the quoted price held?
- What could change it, and what could not?
- When, and how, is payment made?
A worked example, with invented numbers
Every figure here is made up to show the arithmetic. None is a current price, a typical fee or anyone’s actual terms, and neither buyer is Aurstream. Suppose you have one-ounce coins of the same type and condition. At the same time, two buyers provide the figures below. Assume the listed charges apply once per shipment, do not change between two and ten coins, and are the only charges. Buyer B’s figure is an estimate until arrival; its illustrated net proceeds assume that figure does not change.
| Terms | Buyer A | Buyer B |
|---|---|---|
| Quoted amount per coin | $1,950 | $1,970 estimated |
| Deductions | $25 handling fee; A pays insured shipping | $60 shipping and insurance + $30 payment fee |
| Selling 2 coins: illustrated net | 2 × $1,950 − $25 = $3,875 | 2 × $1,970 − $90 = $3,850 |
| Selling 10 coins: illustrated net | 10 × $1,950 − $25 = $19,475 | 10 × $1,970 − $90 = $19,610 |
| Price fixed | when you accept, provided the metal arrives within five business days | when the metal arrives |
Using the displayed figures, A produces $25 more for two coins, while B produces $135 more for ten. But B’s price is not fixed until arrival, so its actual price and proceeds could be higher or lower. The arithmetic compares the stated figures; it does not remove the difference in price certainty. Neither buyer is better in every situation.
A short checklist
Same items · same day and time · the reference each buyer uses · bid per item · every deduction · when the price is fixed and for how long · when and how you are paid · net amount.
If the metals are in an IRA
The same price-comparison principles apply to IRA-held metals. The sale also needs to follow the custodian’s authorization, release and settlement procedures, and account or depository charges may affect the outcome. See IRA metals: sale, distribution or custodian transfer?.
If you are thinking of selling
In Aurstream’s process, an indicative range comes first and is only an estimate. A formal quote states the exact amount and is valid for two hours, and accepting it within that time commits Aurstream to that amount for the agreed products and quantities. The valuation process explains those steps. You can still note what you hold, so that any bid you ask for, from anyone, is for exactly the same items.
This page is general education, not investment or tax advice.
Sources. CFTC and FINRA, 10 Things to Ask Before Buying Physical Gold, Silver or Other Metals, March 20, 2024 (finra.org; also published by the CFTC) · CFTC customer advisory, Beware of Gold and Silver Schemes Designed to Drain Your Retirement Savings, issued August 2020 (historical advisory) (cftc.gov) · United States Mint, bullion coins and bullion coin specifications (usmint.gov) · LBMA, about the daily auction prices and guide to the London market: the price (lbma.org.uk) · NIST Handbook 44, Appendix C, units of measurement (nist.gov) · CME Group glossary (cmegroup.com) · FTC, Investing in Collectible Coins, May 2011 (historical publication, archived by GovInfo). The historical FTC source is cited for coin-market definitions, not its tax or investment recommendations.